Panel #7A

"Conflicts and Atrocities Along the Nile Valley "


The Nile in Egyptian Sudanese Relations and the Search for its Sources

Gaby Warburg
Haifa University, Israel

The Nile sources have become an intriguing puzzle for European and other travelers in that region, especially during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. My reason for writing this paper is to try and suggest reasons for this quest, which at times went beyond pure logic. First, as suggested by the title, I will deal with "the unity of the Nile Valley." In modern times Egypt under Muhammad 'Ali conquered the Sudan in 1821. One of the prime reasons stated by the conquerors was the unity of the Nile Valley. Historically the slogan of those advocating unity between Sudan and Egypt was always the "Unity of the Nile Valley" and not the "Unity of Egypt and the Sudan", since the Nile was the bond uniting the two regions, not its people.
Secondly, Egypt and Sudan have a combined population of over 100 million people who depend on the Nile as their main water source for both agriculture and daily usage, hence its centrality in their survival. With the exception of the Atbara River, which joins the Nile in the Sudan, all its other sources originate south of Sudan and Egypt and thus are beyond their control. There are ten states feeding on the Nile basin and there is no basin-wide agreement among these ten states, hence a water crisis is likely to occur at any moment in the future. In a way such a crisis is already known to us since Biblical times and whenever the waters of the Nile diminished it frightened the people living in its valley, on the one hand, and remained a puzzle which they failed to solve, on the other hand. The enormous loss of waters in the sudd barrier along the White Nile in southern Sudan, and its attempted solution in digging the Jongley Canal, was also a reason for conflict between southern and northern Sudanese.
Thirdly, a unique collection of letters which spans ten years in the lives of John Speke and Richard Burton encompasses their search for the source of the White Nile. This collection, consisting primarily of letters to and from Richard Burton, known as the “Letter Book”, was recently published and contains some new information about their attempts to discover its source.
Finally, as we now know, the source of the White Nile is in Burundi, as discovered by a German traveler in the 1930s. Robert Collins, in his book "Waters of the Nile", writes "from that spring in Burundi, marked by a modest pyramid perched atop a hill of lush green grass with the succinct inscription 'Caput Nili Meridianissimum' (southernmost source of the Nile) the great  river begins." Whether this is the final chapter in this saga is too early to state, however, even should another source be discovered more to the south, it is now quite certain that the Nile, whatever its source, will have to be shared by a large number of states, feeding well over one hundred people and hence the just way of sharing its waters and safeguarding it, is crucial.


The River War Revisited: Sudanese Battalions in the Nile Campaign, 1896-1899

Ron Lamothe
Boston University

Though the defeat the Khalifa Abdullahi and his Mahdist army has been chronicled numerous times since Lord Kitchener “reconquered” the Sudan just over a century ago, we still know little about the Africans who fought in this campaign.  Historians have time and again described the ill-fated “charge of the 21st Lancers” at Omdurman, for example, yet they tend to ignore the more critical role in the battle played by the Sudanese battalions in the Anglo-Egyptian army.  Moreover, one gets the impression from reading these often rather jingoistic accounts that the larger Nile Campaign of 1896-99 was won by British redcoats and not Egyptian and Sudanese conscripts (who made up some two-thirds of the troops).  This paper attempts to remedy this long-running distortion, focusing on the experience of Africans in the Nile Campaign, and in particular, by examining the unique status of the Sudanese infantry battalions.  By returning to the firsthand accounts of embedded journalists, perhaps a fuller picture of events will emerge, and the experience of these Africans will begin to find a place in the African and imperial historiography.  This paper focuses on three previously ignored aspects of the campaign, and one that begs a general re-examination:  first, the entourage of African women who accompanied the Sudanese troops up the Nile; second, the interactions between Sudanese and British soldiers in the Anglo-Egyptian army, as well as those between the Sudanese and Egyptian battalions; third, the interactions between Sudanese soldiers and other Sudanese—military and civilian—whom they encountered during the campaign; and finally, a reconsideration of the battle performance record of these Sudanese soldiers. 


Slavery, Slave Raids and Resistance: Communication and the Flexibility of Stateless Militaries in Nineteenth-Century South Sudan

Stephanie Beswick
Ball State University, USA

This presentation forms part of an ongoing monograph about slavery, slave raids and resistance of peoples in Southern Sudan and focuses on the mid to latter nineteenth century. The coming of the Egyptian colonial era in Southern Sudan introduced a level of intra-Southern communication hitherto unknown. The evolvement of this phenomenon, paradoxically provided some of the first opportunities to first understand the new influx of Egyptian and northern Sudanese foreigners in this war-torn region while simultaneously providing a means of resistance. Among the Dinka, who were the hardest hit of all Southerners during this slaving era, changes took place to accommodate this new perception of shared intra-Southern repression. Indeed it became clear there was a unified need to resist. Among the military innovations during this era, typical of stateless societies generally, was a change in the age-set system; often viewed as merely a structure of social organization it was one that, certainly within the Dinka and possibly other Nilotic cultural societies in the south, doubled as warrior military organizations during times of extreme military stress. This presentation will thus focus on new communication systems and military changes.


The Southern Blue Nile: Tales of Insurgency and Counter-Insurgency

 Wendy James
Oxford University

The Southern Blue Nile region, also sometimes referred to as the southern Funj, or the Ingessana Hills, is often represented as lying 'in between' the North and the South of the Sudan.  It can equally be seen as linking them, literally a point of human contact and interchange, providing passage between the former Upper Nile and Blue Nile provinces, as well as a route of passage between the Sudan and Ethiopia.  In itself, in geographical, economic, and cultural terms, not to mention international involvements, it is a microcosm of the whole of the Sudan.  In the course of the civil war since 1983, the front line has advanced and retreated northwards and south again several times.  The region has experienced the arrival of the SPLA, and its appealing message to local, marginalized populations, and has also suffered the full range of government and militia reprisals, resulting in deaths, displacements, and deep distrust of any authority.  Many characteristics of the civil war as a whole can be seen in the pattern of its impact in this small region.  Reports from Darfur in 2004-5, for example, echo reports from the Southern Blue Nile from the late 1980s onward.  The current situation in Darfur has become known to a global audience, who can scarcely believe the gap between what the Khartoum regime says and what it does.  A better understanding of earlier phases of the war, which had little publicity at the time, can help contextualize the current news from Darfur. Accounts will be quoted from informants on the ground, collected over the period 1988-2000.